Sustainable unemployment in the US could be as low as 3.5 per cent, the president of the San Francisco Federal Reserve said on Wednesday, outlining a level well below what the Fed had traditionally used as the baseline for its labour market policy.
“We have become a humbler Fed, and I have a little humility about what full employment really means,” Mary Daly told the Financial Times’ European Financial Forum in Dublin.
She said the Fed’s “listening events”, in which officials have toured the US to meet businesses and workers, had shown that America’s households and employees believe there is “still room to run in the labour market”, even with unemployment close to record lows.
A lower sustainable unemployment rate gives the Fed the freedom to hold US interest rates low as it tries to bring inflation up to its target.
Unlike central banks in other developed economies, the Fed has two mandates: stable prices and maximum employment. Concern about runaway inflation has taken a back seat and it has signalled that it is willing to let the unemployment rate get even lower, if it can.
The Fed’s most recent projection of the long-term unemployment rate showed a median estimate among policymakers of 4.1 per cent. That estimate stood as high as 5 per cent in 2011, and has crept down steadily since.
Ms Daly added that she has been “wrong before, repeatedly” on the natural unemployment level, having previously set it at 4.5 per cent, 4.2 per cent and 4 per cent. The Fed keeps its projections anonymous, but at least one policymaker had the rate as low as 3.6 per cent in December.
The comments from one of the Fed’s foremost labour experts come a week after data revealed that the US economy added far more jobs than forecast last month and continued to bring workers back into the labour force. The national unemployment rate ticked up only slightly to 3.6 per cent from the 50-year-low of 3.5 per cent recorded in December.
Recent employment data prompted US President Donald Trump to claim an ‘incredible result” in boosting the US economy in his State of the Union speech.
Asked whether the actual natural level of unemployment could be as low as 3 per cent, Ms Daly said: “It would be hard for me to write down a number below three ex ante. I don’t have that in my head. I’m thinking more around what it is now, around 3.5 per cent.”
She added: “Learning about what the natural rate of unemployment is experientially is really important. By experientially I mean look at the data, watch how it comes in, keep track of the relationship between unemployment and inflation, unemployment and wage inflation, and we’ll see it.
“If there’s no tension between unemployment and wage inflation then it’s hard to say that we’re at full employment.”

